Network Dynamics of Technology Diffusion in International Arms Transfers

This article explores the role of technology proliferation within the international arms trade as the major part of political structure of international system. The first part of the article suggests a brief overview of the existing studies of international arms transfer as an integral system in international relations, specifically emphasizing the impact of Krause’s (1992) “diffusion of technology” theoretical concept on the literature of 1990–2000-s. The focus of the review is on the intersection between the studies of specific technological transfers and more generalized empirical research works reveals an interesting scientific puzzle – on the one hand key arms manufacturer states accumulate most of the military R&D thus securing their place on the top of the suppliers’ hierarchy, but on the other hand more and more states acquire capabilities to produce military hardware and they more willingly interact with each other establishing strong horizontal bonds with each other to achieve some political independence and maximize economic efficiency (so-called globalization of arms production). In the second part of the article, the network-based approach is suggested as a solution to the market-hierarchy paradox, with some overview of the latest research of arms transfers via Social Network Analysis (SNA) methodology. The third and the last part of the article provides first empirical investigation of the international military technology transfers using original operationalization approach based on SIPRI Arms Transfer Database information of localized production interstate transfers. Finally, the network graphs are constructed to compare general centrality metrics and locate network communities using the Blondel’s method for community detection. The network topology demonstrates significant interconnections between secondary suppliers within technology transfers sub-network, compared to “regular” transfers sub-network, as well as the existence of a “feedback loop” for the license transfers. Overall the empirical results provide positive evidence for Krause’s “diffusion of technology” concept and also support previous network studies of dissimilarities between USA and USSR dependent sub-network – the asymmetry between them appears to be even more stark on the license transfers data.

1. Acosta M., Coronado D., & Marín R. (2011). Potential Dual-use of Military Technology: Does Citing Patents Shed Light on this Process? Defence and Peace Economics. Vol. 22. No. 3. P. 335–349.

2. Acosta M., Coronado D., Marín R., Prats P. (2013). Factors affecting the diffusion of patented military technology in the field of weapons and ammunition. Scientometrics. Vol. 94. No. 1. P. 1–22.

3. Akerman A., Seim A.L. (2014). The global arms trade network 1950–2007. Journal of Comparative Economics. Vol. 42. No. 3. P. 535–551.

4. Anderton C. H. (1995). Economics of arms trade. In: K. Hartley, T. Sandler. (ed) Handbook of Defense economics. Elsevier Science B.V. Vol. 1. P. 523–561.

5. Anthony I. (1993). The ‘third tier’ countries: production of major weapons. In: H. Wulf. (ed) Arms industry limited. Oxford: Oxford University Press. P. 362–383.

6. Barabási A. L., Aldana-Gonzales M. (2003). Linked: The New Science of Networks. Physics Today. Vol. 56. P. 71–72.

7. Barabási A.L., Bonabeau E. (2003). Scale-free networks. Scientific American. 2003. Vol. 288. No. 5. P. 60–69.

8. Bitzinger R. (1994) The globalization of the arms industry: The next proliferation challenge. International Security. Vol. 19. No. 2. P. 170–198.

9. Bitzinger R. (2003). Towards a Brave New Arms Industry? Adelphi series. Routledge. 104 p.

10. Bitzinger R. (2015). Russian arms transfers and Asian military modernisation. S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies. 14 p.

11. Bitzinger R. A., Kim M. (2005). Why do small states produce arms? The case of South Korea. The Korean journal of defense analysis. Vol. 17. No. 2. P. 183–205.

12. Blackaby F.T. (1971). The Arms Trade with the Third World. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell. 910 p.

13. Blondel V.D., Guillaume J.L., Lambiotte R., Lefebvre E. (2008). Fast unfolding of communities in large networks. Journal of statistical mechanics: theory and experiment. No. 10. P. 10008.

14. Bove V., Elia L., Pelliccia M. (2016). Centrality in trade networks and investment in security. Peace Economics, Peace Science and Public Policy. Vol. 22. No. 1. P. 27–39.

15. Brzoska M. (1999). Economic factors shaping arms production in less industrialized countries. Defence and Peace Economics. Vol. 10. No. 2. P. 139–169.

16. Bull H., Watson A. (1984). The expansion of international society. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1984. 490 p.

17. Bunevich K.G. (2008). Voenno-tekhnicheskoe sotrudnichestvo Rossijskoj Federacii s inostrannymi gosudarstvami v sisteme voenno-ekonomicheskoj bezopasnosti [Military-technical cooperation of the Russian Federation with foreign states in the system of military-economic security]. Nacional’nye interesy: prioritety i bezopasnost. No. 8. P. 11–18.

18. Bunevich K.G. (2014). Transformaciya voenno-tekhnicheskogo sotrudnichestva v usloviyah globalizatsii [Transformation of military-technical cooperation in the context of globalization]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta imeni S.Y. Vitte. Seriya 1: Ekonomika i upravlenie. Vol. 9. No. 3. P. 47–52.

19. Bunevich K.G., Brodunov A.N. (2015). Sovmestnye rossijsko-indijskie razrabotki i proizvodstvo produkcii voennogo naznacheniya (na primere otdel’nyh otraslej voennogo proizvodstva) [Joint Russian-Indian development and production of military products (on the example of certain branches of military production)]. Transportnoe delo Rossii. No. 2. P. 49–52.

20. Caruso R., Di Domizio M. (2016). Interdependence between US and European military spending: a panel cointegration analysis (1988–2013). Applied Economics Letters. Vol. 23. No. 4. P. 302–305.

21. Cvetcyh A.V., Erygin YU.V., Levchen S.V. (2017). Kreativnoe innovacionnoe razvitie predpriyatij oboronnopromyshlennogo kompleksa Rossii: neobhodimost’ i sushchnost [Creative innovative development of enterprises of the military-industrial complex of Russia: necessity and essence]. Menedzhment social’nykh i ekonomicheskikh system. Vol. 7. No. 3.

22. Degterev D.A. (2015). Setevoj analiz mezhdunarodnyh otnoshenij [Network analysis of international relations]. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. Politologiya. Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. No. 4. P. 119–138.

23. Dunne J.P., Brauer J. (2005). Arms trade offsets and development. Africanus. Vol. 35. No. 1. P. 14–24. Engelbrecht H.C. Hanighen F.C. (1934). Merchants of death. Ludwig von Mises Institute. 308 p.

24. Evtod’eva M.G. (2018). Novyj etap voenno-tekhnicheskogo sotrudnichestva Rossii i Kitaya [A new stage in military-technical cooperation between Russia and China. Far East problems]. Problemy Dal’nego Vostoka. No. 4. P. 68–78.

25. Fruchterman T.M.J., Reingold E.M. (1991). Graph drawing by force-directed placement. Software: Practice and experience. Vol. 21. No. 11. P. 1129–1164.

26. Gellner E., Breuilly J. (1983). Nations and nationalism. Vol. 1. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. 161 p.

27. Gerner D.J. (1983). Arms transfers to the Third World: Research on patterns, causes and effects. International Interactions. Vol. 10. No. 1. P. 5–37.

28. Golichenko O. (2012). Modeli razvitiya, osnovannogo na diffuzii tekhnologij. [Development models based on technology diffusion]. Voprosy ekonomiki. No. 4. P. 117–131.

29. Hafner-Burton E.M., Kahler M., Montgomery A.H. (2009). Network analysis for international relations. International Organization. Vol. 63. No. 3. P. 559–592.

30. Hanneke S., Fu W., Xing E. (2010). Discrete temporal models of social networks. Electronic Journal of Statistics. Vol. 4. P. 585–605.

31. Harkavy R.E. (1975). The Arms Trade and International Systems. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger. 291 p.

32. Hartley K. (2009). Arms Industry and the Globalisation. In: J. K. Galbraith, J. Brauer, L. L. Webster. (ed) Process Economics of Peace and Security. Oxford: Eolss Publishers Co. P. 240–247.

33. Hartley K. (2007). The arms industry, procurement and industrial policies. In: T. Sandler, K. Hartley. (ed). Handbook of defense economics. Vol. 2. Amsterdam: North-Holland. P. 1139–1176.

34. Hayward K. (2000). The Globalisation of Defence Industries. Survival. Vol. 42. No. 2. P. 115–132.

35. Heinrich M.N. (2015). The Eurofighter Typhoon programme: economic and industrial implications of collaborative defence manufacturing. Defence Studies. Vol. 15. No. 4. P. 341–360.

36. Holtom P., Bromley M., Simmel V. (2012). Measuring International Arms Transfers. SIPRI. [Electronic source]. URL: https://www.sipri.org/sites/default/files/files/FS/SIPRIFS1212.pdf (accessed: 23.01.2020).

37. Howard M. (1976). War in European History. Cambridge: MIT Press. P. 1–172.

38. Katz J.E. (1984). Arms Production in Developing Countries: An Analysis of Decision Making. Free Press. Lexington, Mass.: D.C. Heath. 371 p.

39. Kennedy M.P. (1987) The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers. New York: Random House. 677 p.

40. Kinne B.J. (2012). Multilateral trade and militarized conflict: Centrality, openness, and asymmetry in the global trade network. The Journal of Politics. Vol. 74. No. 1. P. 308–322.

41. Kinne B.J. (2016). Agreeing to arm: Bilateral weapons agreements and the global arms trade. Journal of Peace Research. Vol. 53. No. 3. P. 359–377.

42. Kinne B.J. (2019) The Defense Cooperation Agreement Dataset (DCAD). Journal of Conflict Resolution. Vol. 64. No. 4. P. 729–755.

43. Kinne B.J., Bunte J.B. (2018). Guns or Money? Defense Co-operation and Bilateral Lending as Coevolving Networks. British Journal of Political Science. Vol. 50. No. 3. P. 1–22.

44. Kinsella D. (1998). Arms transfer dependence and foreign policy conflict. Journal of Peace Research. 1998. Vol. 35. No. 1. P. 7–23.

45. Kinsella D. (2000). Arms production in the third tier: An analysis of opportunity and willingness. International Interactions. Vol. 26. No. 3. P. 253–286.

46. Kinsella D. (2006). The black market in small arms: examining a social network. Contemporary Security Policy. Vol. 27. No. 01. P. 100–117.

47. Kinsella D. (2011). The arms trade. In: Coyne Ch. Mathers R. (ed) The handbook on the political economy of war. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. P. 217–243.

48. Kinsella D. (2014). Illicit arms transfers to Africa and the prominence of the former Soviet bloc: a social network analysis. Crime, Law and Social Change. Vol. 62. No. 5. P. 523–547.

49. Kinsella D.T. (2004). Power transition theory and the global arms trade: Exploring constructs from social network analysis. Fifth Power Transition Conference, Carmel. 31 p.

50. Kinsella D.T. (2003). Changing structure of the arms trade: A social network analysis. Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association. Philadelphia PA. 43 p.

51. Kolesnikov A.V. (2004) Voenno-tekhnicheskoe sotrudnichestvo Rossijskoj Federacii v sovremennyh usloviyah. PhD Dissertation Abstract. Moscow: Voennyj universitet. 22 p.

52. Krause K. (1990). The political economy of the international arms transfer system: the diffusion of military technique via arms transfers. International Journal. Vol. 45. No. 3. P. 687–722.

53. Krause K. (1992). Arms and the State: Patterns of Military Production and Trade. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 299 p.

54. Kushnir A.M. (2008). Voenno-tekhnicheskoe sotrudnichestvo Rossijskoj Federacii s inostrannymi gosudarstvami v sisteme voenno-ekonomicheskoj bezopasnosti [Military-technical cooperation of the Russian Federation with foreign states in the system of military-economic security]. Armiya i obshchestvo. No. 1. P. 64–73.

55. Laurance E.J. (1992). The international arms trade. Lexington Books. 280 p.

56. Leiss A., Geoffrey K., Hoagland J., Refson J., Fischer H. (1970). Arms Transfers to Less Developed Countries, Report No. c/70-1. Cambridge: Center for International Studies. MIT. 56 p.

57. Louscher D.J., Salomone M.D. (2019). Technology transfer and US security assistance: The impact of Licensed Production. New York: Routledge. 202 p.

58. Lupu Y., Traag V.A. (2013). Trading communities, the networked structure of international relations, and the Kantian peace. Journal of Conflict Resolution. Vol. 57. No. 6. P. 1011–1042.

59. Makienko K. (2012). S oruzhiem [With arms]. Rossiya v Global’noj politike. 2012. No. 5. P. 177–188.

60. Maoz Z. (2009). The effects of strategic and economic interdependence on international conflict across levels of analysis. American Journal of Political Science. Vol. 53. No. 1. P. 223–240.

61. Maoz Z. (2012) How network analysis can inform the study of international relations. Conflict Management and Peace Science. Vol. 29. No. 3. P. 247–256.

62. Mawdsley J. (2013). The A400M project: from flagship project to warning for European defence cooperation. Defence studies. Vol. 13. No. 1. P. 14–32.

63. Neuman S.G. (1984). Industrial stratification and Third World military industries. International Organisation. Vol. 38. No. 1. P. 167–197.

64. Nolan J.E. Military Industry in Taiwan and South Korea. Palgrave Macmillan, 1986. 205 p.

65. Orlov A.O., Chepovskij A.A. (2017). O svojstvah modulyarnosti i aktual’nyh korrektirovkah algoritma Blondelya [About modularity properties and actual adjustments of Blondel’s algorithm]. Vestnik Novosibirskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Informacionnye tekhnologii. Vol. 15. No. 3. P. 64–73.

66. Pardesi M.S., Matthews R. (2007). India’s Tortuous Road to Defence-Industrial Self-Reliance. Defence & Security Analysis. Vol. 23. No. 4. P. 419–438.

67. Pearson F.S. (1987). Problems and Prospects of Arms Transfer Limitations Among Second-tier Suppliers: The Cases of France, the United Kingdom, and the Federal Republic of Germany. In: Ohlson. T. (ed) Arms Transfer Limitations and Third World Security. Oxford: Oxford University Press. P. 126–156.

68. Ross A.L. (1994). Developing Countries. In: Pierre A.J. (ed) Cascade of Arms: Managing Conventional Weapons Proliferation. Washington DC: Brookings Institution Press. P. 90–130.

69. Schmid J. (2018). The diffusion of military technology. Defence and Peace Economics. Vol. 29. No. 6. P. 595–613.

70. Shvydun S. (2020). Influence of Countries in the Global Arms Transfers Network: 1950–2018. In: Cherifi H., Galto S., Mendes J.F., Rocha L.M. (ed) Studies in Computational Intelligence. Springer. Vol. 882: Complex Networks and Their Applications VIII Part 2. P. 736–748.

71. SIPRI. (2018). New register function. Accompanying database documentation SIPRI Arms Transfer Database: Deals and TIV. 4 p.

72. SIPRI. (2019). The SIPRI Arms transfers database. URL: https://www.sipri.org/databases/armstransfers (accessed: 23.01.2019).

73. Thompson W. R. (1988). On global war: Historical-structural approaches to world politics. University of South Carolina Press. 315 p.

74. Thurner P.W., Schmid C.S., Cranmer S.J., Kauermann G. (2019). Network interdependencies and the evolution of the international arms trade. Journal of Conflict Resolution. Vol. 63. No. 7. P. 1736–1764.

75. Vashchenko O.A., Bogdanova E.L., Samohvalov D.V., Vorob’ev, O.V. (2015). Problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya proizvodstva importnyh obrazcov vooruzheniya i voennoj tekhniki v Tamozhennom Soyuze. [Problems of legal regulation of the production of imported weapons and military equipment in the Customs Union]. Pravo intellektual’noj sobstvennosti. No. 2. P. 37–39.

76. Vucetic S., Nossal K.R. (2013). The international politics of the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter. International Journal. Vol. 68. No. 1. P. 3–12.

77. Wallerstein I. (1974). The Modern World System, Volume I. New York: Academic Press. 410 p.

78. Wallerstein I. (1980). The future of the world-economy. In: Hopkins T., Wallerstein I. (ed.) Processes of the world-system. Beverly Hills: Sage. P. 167–180.

79. Wallerstein I. (1980). The Modern World System, Volume II. New York: Academic Press, 1980. 372 p.

80. Wulf H. (1985). Arms Production in the Third World. In: SIPRI Yearbook 1985: World Armaments and Disarmament. Oxford: Oxford University Press. P. 329–344.

81. Zadorina A.M. (2016). Voenno-tekhnicheskoe i ekonomicheskoe sotrudnichestvo Rossii i Indii v strategii postroeniya mnogopolyarnogo mira [Military-technical and economic cooperation between Russia and India in the strategy of building a multipolar world]. Mezhdunarodnoe sotrudnichestvo evrazijskih gosudarstv: politika, ekonomika, pravo. Vol. 8. No. 3. P. 19–29.