The Republic of Korea Between China and the United States in the Face of Confrontation Over Taiwan

The article gives a tentative analysis of factors impacting the domestic and foreign policy of the Republic of Korea amid the growing confrontation between the “global West” spearheaded by the U.S. and the “global East” led by Russia and China. While the conflict between Washington and Beijing is being escalated, the South Korean leadership is likely to find itself in a precarious situation where it has to make a choice between its main economic partner and theideological overlord in terms of value orientation and security . Understanding the upcoming political course of Seoul, especially in light of the conflict over Taiwan, is of great scientific value and is important for applied international relations studies. Based on the analysis of the main trends of global turbulence and regional security, the authors propose a scenario prognosis developed on the basis of situational analysis and author’s modeling techniques , which would include both the general trends of the country’s foreign policy and the level of potential involvement of South Korea into a probable conflict between the U.S. and China in the Taiwan Strait. It is also worth noting that the most evident outcome will be the preserved alliance with Washington which is closer to South Korea when it comes to its social and political values and a gradual deterioration in relations with China, the speed of which may vary. However, the authors conclude by saying that Seoul will go to great lengths to postpone this uneasy choice and will try to distance itself from direct participation in a military conflict.

1. Ahremenko A.S. (1999). Stsenarnyy metod prognozirovaniya politicheskikh protsessov [Scenario method of forecasting political processes]. PhD thesis. ::Moscow, Faculty of Philosophy, Moscow State University, Department of the Political Process of Russia. 153 p.

2. Ahremenko A.S. (2006). Politicheskiy analiz I prognozirovanie [Political Analysis and Forecasting]. Moscow: GARDARIKI. 333 p.

3. Asmolov K.V. (2022). O prichinakh rosta antikitayskikh nastroeniy v Yuzhnoy Koree [On the reasons for the growth of anti-Chinese sentiment in South Korea]. Kitay v mirovoy i regiona’'noy politike. Istoriya i sovremennos’'. No. 27. P. 254–267. DOI: 10.48647ZIFES.2022.74.22.015.

4. Asmolov K.V., Solo’'ev A.V. (2021). Strategicheskaya avtonomiya Respubliki Koreya: intellektua’'naya khimera ili politicheskaya rea’'nos’'? [Strategic autonomy for ROC: intellectual pipe dream or political reality?]. Mezhdunarodnaya analitika. Vol. 12. No. 2. P. 49–73.

5. Babaev K.V. (2023). Vsya «Indo-Tikhookeanskaya» ra’': istemaa voenno-politicheskikh soyuzov sShA v Indiyskom i Tikhom okeanakh “"All the Indo-Pacific Me”": The System of US Political and Military Pacts in the Indian Ocean and Asia Pacific]. Kontury globa’'nykh transformatsiy. Vol. 16. No 1. In print.

6. Cheng Hyunwook. (2021). 중국-대만 경제교류의 새로운 정치 쟁점: 시민 정체성과 경제 적 합리성 [New Political Issues in China-Taiwan Economic Exchange: Civic Identity and Economic Rationality (In Kor.)]. Culture and Politics. Vol. 8. No. 2. P. 5–32.

7. Chi Eun-Jung. (2020). 지은주 / 시진핑 집권 이후 중국의 대만정책과 양안관계 [China's Taiwan Policies after Xi Jin-ping and the Cross-Strait Relationship (In Kor.)]. International Territorial Studies. Vol. 29. No. 4. P. 113–144.

8. Choe Woo-sung. (2022). 대만 군사충돌 시나리오와 한국의 대응 [Taiwan Military Conflict Scenario and South Korea’s Response (In Kor.)]. IFANS. Vol. 2021. No. 51. P. 1–22.

9. Cho Sung-min. (2023). 양안문제: 대만 해협의 무력충돌 가능성과 한국에 미칠 영향 [Cross-strait Issues: The Possibility of armed conflict in the Taiwan Strait and its Impact on South Korea (In Kor.)]. IFANS. Vol. 2023. No. 4. P. 56–69.

10. Dikarev A.D., Lukin A. V. (2021). “Tayvan'skaya natsiya”: ot mifa k real'nosti? [Taiwan Nation: From Myth to Reality?]. Comparative Politics Russia. Vol. 12. No. 1. P. 118–133.

11. Erofeev V.K., Karyagin N.E., Nozdrina E.G. (1998). Stsenarnoye modelirovanie kak tekhnologiya prinyatiya gruppovykh resheniy [Scenario modeling as a technology for making group decisions]. Astrakhan': Izdvo Astrahanskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta. 64 p.

12. Inhan Kim. (2023). 중국 국력 성장과 동아시아 해양 분쟁의 격화 가능성 : 남중국해, 대 만해협, 동중국해를 중심으로 [The Rise of China and the Prospects for Maritime Disputes (In Kor.)]. NEW ASIA. Vol. 21. No. 1. P. 24–49.

13. Kaimova A.S. (2013). Problemy interpretatsii ponyatiya “tayvan'skaya identichnost'” [Problems of Interpreting the Notion of “Taiwanese Identity”]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta, Seriya “Vostokovedenie”. No. 2. P. 27–38.

14. Kang Jun Young. (2022). 중국-대만, 양안 무력 충돌 위기의 함의 -미국의 대만 지원 및 갈등 시나리오를 중심으로 [Reality of Armed Conflict between China and Taiwan -Focusing on the Scenario of US Support and Conflict in Taiwan]. Korean-Chinese Social Science Studies. Vol. 20. No. 1. P. 9–32.

15. Kwon Ki-chang. (2022). 우크라이나 전쟁 현황과 전망 – 중·러관계, 중·대만 양안관계, 한 국에 주는 시사점 [The Ukraine War: The Current Status and Future Prospect, Russo-Chinese Relations, China-Taiwan Relations and Its Implication to the Republic of Korea]. Foreign Relations. Vol. 142. No. 7. P. 151–165.

16. Kim E., Cha V. (2016). Between a Rock and a Hard Place: South Korea’s Strategic Dilemmas with China and the United States. Asia Policy. No. 21. P. 101–122.

17. Lempert R. (2007). “Can Scenarios Help Policymakers Be Both Bold and Careful?” in F. Fukuyama (ed.) Blindside: How to Anticipate Forcing Events and Wild Cards in Global Politics. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press. P. 109–119.

18. Martynova D.O. «Indo-Tikhookeanskaya strategiya» vo vneshney politike Respubliki Koreya [The “IndoPacific Strategy” in the foreign policy of the Republic of Korea]. Koreanology. 2023. No. 1(2). P. 79–80.

19. Matveev N. S. (2012). Stsenarnyi podkhod v prognozirovanii pokazatelei natsional'noi ekonomiki [Scenario approach in forecasting the indicators of the national economy] [Electronic source]. Sovremennye nauchnye issledovaniya i innovatsii. No. 6. URL: https://web.snauka.ru/issues/2012/06/15630 (accessed: 23.06.2023).

20. Primakov E.M., Khrustalev M.A. (2006). Situatsionnye analizy. Metodika provedeniya. Ocherki tekushchey politiki T. 1 [Situational analyses. The methodology of conducting. Essays on current politics. Vol. 1]. Moscow: Nauchno-obrazovatel'niy forum po mezhdunarodnym otnosheniyam, MGIMO. 28 p.

21. Torkunov A.V. (2008). Koreyskiy poluostrov: metamorfozy poslevoennoy istorii [Korean peninsula: metamorphosis of the post-war history]. Moscow: OLMA. 544 p.

22. Vanin Yu. V. (2006). Koreyskaya voyna (1950–1953) i OON [The Korean War (1950–1953) and the UN]. Moscow: In-t vostokovedeniya RAN. 286 p.