Regulatiing lobbying in international and transnational spheres. Legal and political aspects

Lobbying is an integral part of contemporary international processes. Globalization, spread of market relations and transnational links, liberalization of national and supranational governance increased the role of interest groups in international relations. However, interest groups activities at the global level are still largely a terra incognita for international relations theory and international law which requires a more comprehensive analysis. The main goal of the article is to fill the gaps in modern IR theory as well as in theories of lobbying and interest groups by systematization of lobbying regulation experience in international and transnational spheres. Even though single approach towards formalization of international lobbying is hardly feasible, systematization of current global practices should facilitate better understanding of the nature of interest groups activity in international and transnational spheres, of potential and limits for its regulation both in sovereign states and international organizations. The article analyzes separate regulatory regimes aimed at formalizing lobbying in international and transnational spheres. There are two types of regimes: those existing on supranational level that set rules of interaction between interest groups and international organisations; those that regulate interactions of foreign interest groups and sovereign states. Analysis has demonstrated that supranational and national authorities have different approaches towards regulating their interactions with transnational interest groups. Moreover, difference exists not only between these two levels but within levels. I study supranational regulation with the cases of the European Union and the United Nations. The EU is an example of the most inclusive regulatory regime within the international organization. It technically covers all types of interest groups that wish to lobby EU officials. The UN takes a different approach – it officially regulates interactions only with international non-governmental organisations (INGOs). However, real interests behind INGOs include not only public interests but also business groups. There is an unfolding discussion within the UN over what should be the right approach towards regulating business interests. Various UN bodies have varying opinions on the issue that results in existence of various sub-regimes in the organization. The analysis of foreign lobbying regulation regimes in sovereign states has demonstrated that their development is connected mainly to political motivations of national authorities who wish to limit political and information influence by foreign interest groups while leaving economic ties and interaction with foreign business groups relatively immune to such regulation.

1. Arras S., Beyers J. (2020). Access to European Union agencies. Usual suspects or balanced interest representation in open and closed consultations? Journal of Common Market. Vol. 58. No. 4. P. 836–855.

2. Bajkov A.A., Sushencov A.A. (2010). Stranovye osobennosti lobbizma v SShA i Japonii [Country Specifics of Lobbying in the US and Japan]. Mezhdunarodnye protsessy. No. 2. P. 100–111.

3. Beyers J., Hanegraaf M., Poletti A., De Bievre D. (2019). International institutions and interest mobilization: The WTO and lobbying in EU and US trade policy. Journal of World Trade. Vol. 50. No. 2. P. 307–310.

4. Beyers J., De Bruycker I. (2019). Lobbying Strategies and Success. Inside and Outside Lobbying in European Union Legislative Politics. European Political Science Review. Vol. 11. No. 1. P. 57–74.

5. Botkina O.N. (2018). Lobbizm v Organizataii Ob’edinennykh Natsij i prava cheloveka [Lobbying in the United Nations and Human Rights]. Gumanitarnaja diplomatija: lichnost', socium i mir. Ekaterinburg: Ural'skij universitet. P. 31–36.

6. Bouwen P. (2002). Corporate lobbying in the European Union: The logic of access. Journal of European Public Policy. Vol. 9. No. 3. P. 365–390.

7. Bunea A. (2018). Legitimacy through targeted transparency? Regulatory effectiveness and sustainability of lobbying regulation in the European Union. European Journal of Political Research. No. 57. P. 378–403.

8. Burns T., Carson M. (2002). European Union Neo-Corporatist, and Pluralist Governance Arrangements: Lobbying and Policy-Making Patterns in a Comparative Perspective. International Journal of Regulation and Governance. Vol. 2. No. 2. P. 129–175.

9. Coen D., Richardson J. (2009). Lobbying the European Union: Institutions, Actors and Issues. Oxford University Press. 373 p.

10. Culpepper P. (2010). Quiet Politics and Business Power: Corporate Control in Europe and Japan. Cambridge University Press. 248 p.

11. Curran L., Eckhardt J. (2017). Smoke screen? The globalization of production, transnational lobbying and the international political economy of plain tobacco packaging. Review of International Political Economy. Vol. 24. No. 1. P. 87–118.

12. Degtereva E. (2008). Lobbizm v processe prinjatija reshenij ES: normy regulirovanija, mehanizmy i modeli [Lobbying in the EU Decision Making Process: Regulatory Norms, Mechanisms and Models]. Mirovaja jekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija. No. 4. P. 42–49.

13. Dellmuth L. (2022). Interest Groups and the United Nations (UN). In: Harris P., Bitonti A., Fleisher C.S., Skorkjær Binderkrantz A. (eds.) The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Interest Groups, Lobbying and Public Affairs. Palgrave Macmillan, 2022 (preprint). URL: https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1527938/FULLTEXT01.pdf (accessed: 21.10.2021).

14. Dür A., De Bièvre D. (2007). Inclusion without Influence? NGOs in European Trade Policy. Journal of Public Policy. No. 27 (1). P. 79–101.

15. Durkee M. (2017). Astroturf Activism. Stanford Law Review. Vol. 69. P. 201–268.

16. Durkee M. (2018). International lobbying law. The Yale Law Journal. Vol. 127. P. 1742–1826.

17. Fel'dman P.Ja. (2015). Mezhdunarodnyj lobbizm v uslovijah global'noj destabilizatsii [International Lobbying in the Context of Global Destabilization]. Mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija. No. 3. P. 336–340.

18. Fuks N.A. (2018). Lobbirovanie v Evropejskom Sojuze: Vlijanie interesov lobbistskih grupp na initsiatsiju zakonodatel'stva Evropejskoj Komissiej (2011–2017 gg.) [Lobbying in the European Union: Influence of the Interests of Lobbying Groups on Initiation of Legislature by the European Commission (2011–2017)]. Biznes. Obshhestvo. Vlast'. No. 30. P. 127–143.

19. Gereke M., Brühl T. (2019). Unpacking the unequal representation of Northern and Southern NGOs in international climate change politics. Third World Quarterly. 2019. Vol. 40. No. 5. P. 870–889.

20. Hanegraaff M., Vergauwen J., Beyers J. (2020). Should I Stay or Should I Go? Explaining Exit and Entry of Non-State Actors at United Nations Climate Summits. Governance. Vol. 33. No. 2. P. 287–304.

21. Hanegraaff M., Poletti A. (2021). The Rise of Corporate Lobbying in the European Union: An Agenda for Future Research. Journal of Common Market Studies. Vol. 59. No. 4. P. 839–855.

22. Holman C., Luneburg W. (2012). Lobbying and Transparency: A Comparative Analysis of Regulatory Reform. Interest Groups & Advocacy. Vol. 1. No. 1. P. 75–104.

23. Hrebenar R., Morgan B. (2009). Lobbying in America: A Reference Handbook. Santa-Barbara. 289 p.

24. Ilyicheva L.E. (2015). Lobbizm v SSHA: opyt funktsionirovaniya [Lobbying in the USA: Experience of Functioning]. Nauchnoe obozrenie. Seriya 2: Gumanitarnye nauki. No. 5. P. 13–20.

25. Joachim J. (2017). NGOs in World Politics. In: Baylis J., Smith S., Owens P. (eds) The Globalization of World Politics. An Introduction to International Relations. Seventh Edition. Oxford. 610 p.

26. Klüver H. (2013). Lobbying in the European Union: Interest Groups, Lobbying Coalitions, and Policy Change. Oxford University Press. 278 p.

27. Kondrat'eva N.B. (2016). Evrazijskij jekonomicheskij sojuz: dostizhenija i perspektivy [Eurasian Economic Union: Achievements and Prospects]. Mirovaja jekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija. Vol. 60. No. 6. P. 15–23.

28. Konyshev V.N., Skvortsova E.M. (2020). Inostrannyj lobbizm kak instrument sotrudnichestva Pol'shi I SShA v oboronnoj sfere. Baltijskij region. No. 2. P. 4–22.

29. Lee J. T.-H. (2020). International Lobbying for Hong Kong. Indian Journal of Asian Affairs. Vol. 33. No. 1/2. P. 108–111.

30. Loshkarev I. D. (2017). Resursy etnicheskogo lobbizma vo vneshney politike SSHA: teoreticheskiye aspekty [Resources of Ethnic Lobbying in US Foreign Policy: Theoretical Aspects]. Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. Vol. 61. No. 3. P. 76–83.

31. Ljubimov A.P. (2005). Istorija lobbizma v Rossii [History of Lobbying in Russia]. Moscow: Fond Liberal'naja missija. 208 p.

32. Mahoney C. (2004). The power of institutions. State and interest group activity in the European Union. European Union Politics. Vol. 5. No. 4. P. 441–466.

33. McWilliams A., Van Fleet D., Cory K. (2002). Raising rivals’ costs through political strategy: An extension of resource-based theory. Journal of Management Studies. Vol. 39. No. 5. P. 707–724.

34. Mearsheimer J., Walt S. (2008). The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy. Farrar, Straus and Giroux. 496 p.

35. Moiseeva D.E. (2017). Lobbizm v Evropejskom sojuze: krizis legitimnosti [Lobbying in the European Union: Legitimacy Crisis]. Moscow: IMEMO RAN. 120 p.

36. Moloo R. (2011). The Quest For Legitimacy In The United Nations: A Role For NGOs? UCLA Journal of International Law and Foreign Affairs. Vol. 16. No. 1. P. 1–40.

37. Moravcsik A. (2008). The European Constitutional Settlement. The World Economy. Vol. 31. No. 1. P. 158–183.

38. Nastase A., Muurmans C. (2020). Regulating lobbying activities in the European Union: A voluntary club perspective. Regulation & Governance. No. 14. P. 238–255.

39. Peregudov S.P. (2009). Lobbizm rossijskogo krupnogo biznesa v Evropejskom sojuze (makrouroven') [Lobbying for the Russian Major Business in the European Union (macrolevel)]. Mirovaja jekonomika I mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija. No. 9. P. 49–63.

40. Peregudov S.P., Utkin A.I., Kostyaev S.S. (2009). Lobbizm rossiyskogo biznesa v SSHA i YES: evolyutsiya i perspektivy [Lobbying of Russian business in the US and the EU: evolution and prospects]. Moscow: ISKRAN. 65 p.

41. Pigman G. (2010). Contemporary Diplomacy. Polity. 288 p.

42. Tolstyh P.A. (2009). Professional'nyj slovar' lobbistskoj dejatel'nosti [Professional Dictionary of Lobbying Activities]. Moscow: Centr po izucheniju problem vzaimodejstvija biznesa i vlasti. 379 p.

43. Robinson N. (2020). “Foreign Agents” in an Interconnected World: FARA and the Weaponization of Transparency. Duke Law Journal. Vol. 69. No. 5. P. 1075–1147.

44. Rudenkova D.E. (2015).Regulirovaniye lobbizma v Yevropeyskom soyuze: istoriya i perspektivy [Lobbying regulation in the European Union: history and prospects]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta: Seriya 25: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya i mirovaya politika. No. 1. P. 152–177.

45. Rutzen D. (2015). Aid Barriers and the Rise of Philanthropic Protectionism. International Journal of Not-for-profit Law. Vol. 17. No. 1. P. 5–44.

46. Senit C.-A., Biermann F. (2021). In Whose Name Are You Speaking? The Marginalization of the Poor in Global Civil Society. Global Policy. Vol. 12, Issue 5. P. 581–591.

47. Shul'ga M.A. (2014). “Defitsit demokratii” v Evropejskom Sojuze: smysly i interpretatsii [“Democracy Deficit” in the European Union: Meanings and Interpretations]. Politicheskaja nauka. No. 2. P. 162–182.

48. Schwarzenberg R. (1992). Politicheskaja sotsiologija: v 3 ch. [Political Sociology in 3 Parts]. Ch.3. Moscow. 157 p.

49. Skonieczny A. (2017). Corporate Lobying in Foreign Policy. In: Oxford Research Encyclopedia in Politics. Oxford University Press, 2017. URL: DOI:10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.420.

50. Stevens F., De Bruycker I. (2020). Influence, affluence and media salience: Economic resources and lobbying influence in the European Union. European Union Politics. Vol. 21. No. 4. P. 728–750.

51. Stoyanov A. (2009). Trade policy of a free trade agreement in the presence of foreign lobbying.Journal of International Economics. Vol. 77. No. 1. P. 37–49.

52. Suchkov M. (2013). Vlijanie lobbi-grupp na formirovanie vneshnej politiki SShA na Juzhnom Kavkaze [Impaxt of Lobby-Groups on Creation of the US Foreign Policy in South Caucasus]. Vestnik MGIMO-Universiteta. No. 3. P. 18–24.

53. Brown G., McLean I., McMillan A. (2018). The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Politics and International Relations. Oxford. (electronic edition).

54. Tidwell A. (2016). The role of ‘diplomatic lobbying’ in shaping US foreign policy and its effects on the Australia–US relationship. Australian Journal of International Affairs. Vol. 71. No. 2. P. 1–17.

55. Vasil'eva V.M. (2011). Mezhdunarodnyj lobbizm: na puti k institucionalizatsii [International Lobbying: on the Path to Institutionalization]. Gosudarstvennoe upravlenie. Jelektronnyj vestnik. No. 29. P. 18–28.

56. Whawell P. (1998). The Ethics of Pressure Groups. Business Ethics: A European Review. Vol. 7. No. 3. P. 178–181.

57. Wiseman G. (1999). “Polylateralism” and New Modes of Global Dialogue. Diplomatic Studies Programme, Center for the Study of Diplomacy. Discussion Paper. No. 59. University of Leicester. 26 p.