Debate around U.S. Foreign Trade Legislation as an Element of Détente in Soviet-American Relations (1969–1979)

Détente in Soviet-American relations throughout the 1970s was a complex and multifaceted process. The interaction of the two states as regards foreign trade, technology transfer and scientific exchanges was an important part of it. On the one hand, according to some détente ideologists, a critical mass of commercial ties along with scientific and technological projects established in accordance with the tenets of equality and mutual benefit could have created conditions for overcoming the Cold War and maintaining peaceful coexistence in the foreseeable future. At the same time, it was in the sphere of foreign trade that sharp disagreements first manifested themselves, indicating a clear-cut rift between the external political goals of the superpowers and the ability of their internal legislative systems to address these challenges. This article is devoted to reviewing the processes of transforming US foreign trade legislation during the détente period. It aims to insert this track into the pattern of forming Washington's course towards the Soviet state from the late 1960s to 1979. The research draws on the documents of both chambers of Congress, revealing the content of the debate on the adoption of export regulation laws and reflecting the views on this issue that existed at that time. The digital documents of the US State Department and Presidents R. Nixon and J. Carter are used to reflect their attitude vis-à-vis trade matters. It is shown how the executive and legislative branches interacted when updating the regulatory framework of foreign trade. The conclusion holds that while maintaining the general liberal vector in drafting foreign trade laws, they have always contained control standards for high-tech products export to socialist countries aimed at curbing scientific and technological progress in the USSR. As a result, the economic, scientific and technical foundation of détente in Soviet-American relations remained feeble and proved inadequate for preventing the confrontational recession in the early 1980s.

1. Arbatov G.A. (1991) Zatyanuvsheesya vyzdorovlenie (1953–1985 gg.). Svidetel’stvo sovremennika [Prolonged recovery (1953–1985 gg.) The contemporarie’s testimony]. Moscow, Меzhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 1991. 400 с.

2. Bange O., Villaume P. (eds) (2017). The Long Détente: changing concepts of security and cooperation in Europe, 1950s – 1980s. Budapest: Central European University Press. 358 p.

3. Batyuk V. I. (2018). Kholodnaya vojna mezhdu SSHA i SSSR (1945–1991). Ocherki istorii. [The Cold War Between the USA and the USSR (1945–1991). History Essays]. Moscow: Ves' Mir. 336 p.

4. Bingham J. B. (1980). The Export Administration Act of 1979: A Congressional Perspective. Proceedings of the ASIL Annual Meeting. Vol. 74. P. 88–94.

5. Chapman B. (2013). Export Controls: A Contemporary History. Washington, DC: University Press of America. 430 р.

6. Cherkasov P.P. (2016) IMEMO. Ocherk istorii. [Essay on IMEMO History]. Izdatelstvo «VES MIR, Moscow». 872 p.

7. Encounters with Kennan (1979). The Great Debate : George Kennan, Leopold Labedz, Melvin J. Lasky, Richard Lowenthal, Richard Pipes, Hugh Seton-Watson, George Urban. London, Frank Cass and Company Ltd. 218 p.

8. Funigiello P. (1988). American-Soviet Trade in the Cold War. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. 357 p.

9. Gaddis J.L. (1987) The Long Peace: Inquiries into the History of the Cold War. N.Y.: Oxford U. P. 332 р.

10. Garthoff R. (1994). Détente and Confrontation. American-Soviet Relations from Nixon to Reagan. Washington: The Brookings Institution. 1147 p.

11. Hanhimaki J. (2013). The rise and fall of détente: American foreign policy and the transformation of the Cold War. Washington, D.C.: Potomac Books. 274 p.

12. Jackson I (2001). The Economic Cold War: America, Britain and East-West Trade, 1948–63. London: Palgrave Macmillan. 239 p.

13. Kissinger H. (1979) White House Years. Boston: Little Brown & Co. P. 1521.

14. Kieninger S. (2016). Dinamic Détente: the United States and Europe, 1964–1975. Lanham: Lexington Boooks. 356 p.

15. Kremenjuk V. (2015) Uroki kholodnoi voiny [The lessons of the Cold War]. Мoscow: ZAO Izdatel’stvo «Aspect Press», 319 p.

16. Lipkin M.A. (2016). Sovetskij Soyuz i integratsionnye protsessy v Evrope: seredina 1940-h – konets 1960-h godov [The Soviet Union and Integration Processes in Europe: mid – 1940s – late 1960s.] Moscow.: Russkij fond sodeistvija obrazovaniju i nauke. 560 р.

17. Loth W. (2002). Overcoming the Cold War: a history of détente, 1950–1991. N.Y.: Palgrave Macmillan. 255 p.

18. Loth W. (2003). Détente and the overcoming of the Cold War. In Yegorova N. I., Chubar'ian A.O. (eds) Kholodnaya vojna i politika razryadki: diskussionnye problemy. V 2-х tomakh. Vol. II. М.: Institut vseobshchei istorii RAN. P. 9–25.

19. Mastanduno M. (1992). Economic Containment: CoCom and Politics of East-West Trade. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. 353 p.

20. Pechatnov V.О. (2021). Kak inache mogla zakonchit'sya kholodnaya voyna? [How Could the Cold War Have Ended Differently?]. In Pavlenko O.V., Zhuravleva V.I. (eds) Оkonchanie kholodnoi voiny v vosprijatii sovremennikov i istorikov : 1985–1991. Мoscow: RGGU. P. 65–77.

21. Pechatnov В.О. (2022). Soviet-American Relations through the Cold War. In Pechatnov В.О. Istoriya i Politika. Мoscow: Aspect Press. С. 361–376.

22. Pipes R. (1981) U.S. – Soviet relations in the Era of Détente. Boulder, Westview Press. 227 p.

23. Sheh I. N. (2008). The Future Almost Arrived: How Jimmy Carter Failed to Change U.S. Foreign Policy. N.Y.: Peter Lang. 372 p.

24. Saull R. (2001). Rethinking theory and history in the Cold War: the state, military power and social revolution. London: Frank Cass Publishers. 238 p.

25. Technology and East-West trade (1979). Washington, D.C.: US GPO, 303 p.

26. Yegorova N. I. (2003). Poniatie «razriadka» v 1950-e gody: sovetskaia i zapadnaia interpretatsii [Détente’s Conception in the 1950s: Soviet and Western Interpretations]. In Yegorova N.I., Chubar'ian A.O. (eds) Kholodnaya vojna i politika razryadki: diskussionnye problemy. V 2-h tomakh. Vol. I. М.: Institut vseobshei istorii RAN. P. 64–90.

27. Yungblyud V.T., Ilyin D.V. (2020). Popravka Dzheksona – Venika i razvitie sovetsko-amerikanskih otnoshenij v 1972–1975 gg. [Jackson–Vanik Amendment and Development of Soviet-American Relations in 1972–1975]. Vestnik MGIMO-Universiteta. Vol.13. No. 2. P. 7–39.